After reading The MTA's Evasion Crackdown: Deterrence, Design, Disparity, you asked “Who gets parole (I mean, fines)?”
Who's Fined, and Why: The Human Face of Fare Enforcement
1 min read
First-time evaders get warnings while repeat offenders face $100+ fines, with Fair Fares participants paying half.
Who gets parole — I mean, fines?
Not everybody walking through a subway gate without paying ends up with a penalty. Starting January 2025, New York's new rules give first-time fare evaders in a 4-year span a warning instead of a fine. Only on the second offense do they face a $100 fine (paid promptly = a $50 OMNY credit), and on the third and beyond, fines can go up to $150 or even a criminal summons in rare cases.
What happens after a Notice of Violation depends on your history. If it's your first offense, you'll likely get a Notice of Warning and no further action. For repeat offenders, a Notice of Fine arrives by mail, telling you exactly how much you owe and your options to contest.
There is a safety net: Fair Fares NYC participants can cut fines in half. And if you aren't enrolled yet but sign up before your hearing, you may get the fine waived once.
Take Action
Discuss
Published October 2, 2025
Rachel Kowalski is a contributor for Tunnel Vision.
This article is part of the Fares series.